MK5 Golf GTI
General => Random Chat => Topic started by: sub39h on July 23, 2016, 02:18:12 pm
-
Hi guys,
Hope you're all well. Slightly odd question this. My car is currently with Alex at AKS with a gearbox fault. After much fault finding it turns out the mechatroncis has failed and is a £1600 replacement which in my opinion is not worth it given the value of the car and the amount I've spent trying to get it sorted to date.
My car is in my sig, has 97k miles on it and is in good condition but of course is a non runner because the gearbox is a paperweight.
What should I do with it? The car is stuck at AKS, some 150 miles away from my home and I need a car for work and am currently abroad until the end of August. I can't really part ex it because I can't get it to a dealer and presume it would be worth nothing to them.
What do people think the car is worth without the mechatronics repair?
Suggestions?
-
Can you not buy a cheap 2nd hand box complete with non faulty mechatronics unit?
-
I had thought about that, but Alex has literally just changed the clutches on my box so I'd be wasting £700+ of parts and labour going down that route. Plus no guarantees that the new box would work properly wasting even more labour costs! I guess given the option the new mechatronics is the safe bet because my gearbox will essentially be fully refurbished and roughly the same cost.
-
No much is my guess. Find a similar spec car on auto trader and take of the cost of the repair plus some.
-
Best to buy a used box imho.
-
As above ^ get the box replaced and then sell.
-
Thanks chaps. I'm looking into a used box plus emailing anyone and everyone for the price of a mechatronics unit. So far best price I have got is £1310 and the chap is going to see if he can get a discount on Monday and get back to me. If possible I'd rather keep the gearbox original because it has new clutches and I know its history.
Any suggestions on best places to look for boxes?
Thanks team.
-
Thanks chaps. I'm looking into a used box plus emailing anyone and everyone for the price of a mechatronics unit. So far best price I have got is £1310 and the chap is going to see if he can get a discount on Monday and get back to me. If possible I'd rather keep the gearbox original because it has new clutches and I know its history.
Any suggestions on best places to look for boxes?
Thanks team.
The guys in Bristol could possibly have your mech repaired for £700 ish.
-
I guess sometimes it's better the devil you know if you have recently spent a fair bit on it. 2nd hand mech unit or cheaper repair of your existing unit would be the best option.
-
Find a crash damaged one in the ebay gti breaking or spend the £700 and you'll have a guaranteed mech unit. :smiley: sad but it's how it is. second hand is a risk imho but it's a cheaper option.
Best of luck.
-
Thanks chaps. I'm looking into a used box plus emailing anyone and everyone for the price of a mechatronics unit. So far best price I have got is £1310 and the chap is going to see if he can get a discount on Monday and get back to me. If possible I'd rather keep the gearbox original because it has new clutches and I know its history.
Any suggestions on best places to look for boxes?
Thanks team.
The guys in Bristol could possibly have your mech repaired for £700 ish.
If they can then that would be the ideal. Alex said it couldn't be repaired, but I'm not sure I trust the guys he sent my unit to. Firstly when they returned it apparently it wasn't in good condition and Alex sent it back to them. Also they didn't find a fault, and then when Alex refitted it it was obvious it had failed. They sound totally useless to me.
But if they're right and it can't be repaired, apparently 2nd hand ones aren't usually possible to obtain because there are dozens of different varieties and softwares so it'll have to either be a whole reconditioned box or a brand new mechatronics.
Let's see what all the mechatronics repair guys come back with, and what prices I can get for a new one. Then I'll take it from there.
-
I'm hoping and praying for you mate :party:
-
I'm hoping and praying for you mate :party:
Thanks mate. I've found a new mechatronics for £1145 now. I've emailed Alex to ask if he can get in touch with the chaps from Bristol. He's a top bloke but I wish he was better at responding to emails!
-
I'm hoping and praying for you mate :party:
Thanks mate. I've found a new mechatronics for £1145 now. I've emailed Alex to ask if he can get in touch with the chaps from Bristol. He's a top bloke but I wish he was better at responding to emails!
Sometimes you need to call the up on the phone as emails are Sucky Sucky :signLOL:
That's a good price for a new one. it'll probably cost you a further 300 fitted with fresh gear oil unless they use the old stuff as it's fresh anyway.
-
I'm hoping and praying for you mate :party:
Thanks mate. I've found a new mechatronics for £1145 now. I've emailed Alex to ask if he can get in touch with the chaps from Bristol. He's a top bloke but I wish he was better at responding to emails!
Where is that from mate?
-
I got a second hand gearbox + mechatronics for £250 - 80k on it. I needed a new box as something in the gearbox wasn't right - the mechatronics was actually fine. However, on this new one, I think there might be a fault with the mechatronics! It really doesn't like being stationary in D with foot on brake, other than that its fine.
Garage is looking at it tomorrow, and if they can sort it somehow it will mean I can release my old mechatronics for sale...