MK5 Golf GTI
All Things Mk5 => Modifications & Technical Area => Cosmetic/Interior Modifications => Topic started by: Hendry on June 05, 2017, 12:51:20 pm
-
Will Golf mk7 stalks fit and work in a mk5? They seem to have the same layout and functions as mk5 ones, only they look nicer and more up to date, is it just the actual cosmetics of the stalks that have changed or is the fitting and connection totally incompatible with them?
I was sort of guessing they might be similar because a lot of VWs and Seats which originally had the same stalks as the mk5 Golf have now had the mk7 style ones fitted as part of the midlife facelift on them. Just need a definite answer before I splash out.
-
No
-
No
:grin: Straight to the point lol have you tried it, is that how you know?
-
They are different, you have both stalks separate, mk7 have both stalks. Different wiring and module as well
-
They are different, you have both stalks separate, mk7 have both stalks. Different wiring and module as well
So what about cars which had mk5 stalks to begin with and now have mk7 stalks such as Seat Ibizas, Skoda Rapid, Seat Toledo, surely they must fit a mk5, cant see them totally changing everything on those cars just to allow a cosmetically different style of stalks.
-
Feel free to buy one and test it mate
-
Feel free to buy one and test it mate
I may well do, theres a brand new genuine mk7 cruise control retrofit (boxed like its a complete kit you can buy from a dealers) which includes both stalks, if they dont work I should be able to sell and recoup most of my expense.
-
It wont fit the mk5..... you seem hell bent on ignoring sound advice above :thinking:
-
It wont fit the mk5..... you seem hell bent on ignoring sound advice above :thinking:
Seat Ibiza, VW Polo, Seat Toledo, Skoda Rapid ALL had mk5 stalks up till about 2014, and now have mk7 stalks, they surely havent completely redesigned everything on those cars to fit stalks that look slightly different, so must be the same fitting as the mk5 ones so must surely work? even if the mk7 ones are a different fitting, surely the mk7 style ones from these cars will fit and work?
-
It wont fit the mk5..... you seem hell bent on ignoring sound advice above :thinking:
Seat Ibiza, VW Polo, Seat Toledo, Skoda Rapid ALL had mk5 stalks up till about 2014, and now have mk7 stalks, they surely havent completely redesigned everything on those cars to fit stalks that look slightly different, so must be the same fitting as the mk5 ones so must surely work? even if the mk7 ones are a different fitting, surely the mk7 style ones from these cars will fit and work?
They surely have.......
I gave you the short answer "No".... I have mk7 stalks sat in my bedroom, totally different.
Alex @olsen-72 (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=4567) gave you the longer answer (he knows what he's doing)
Rich @rich83 (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=709) also has given you the answer.....
Anyhow, go buy a set and see how you get on
As for the other post.... VW MFSW MK7 Polo steering wheel in Mk5
Not even going there...sorry!
-
It wont fit the mk5..... you seem hell bent on ignoring sound advice above :thinking:
Seat Ibiza, VW Polo, Seat Toledo, Skoda Rapid ALL had mk5 stalks up till about 2014, and now have mk7 stalks, they surely havent completely redesigned everything on those cars to fit stalks that look slightly different, so must be the same fitting as the mk5 ones so must surely work? even if the mk7 ones are a different fitting, surely the mk7 style ones from these cars will fit and work?
They surely have.......
I gave you the short answer "No".... I have mk7 stalks sat in my bedroom, totally different.
Alex @olsen-72 (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=4567) gave you the longer answer (he knows what he's doing)
Rich @rich83 (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=709) also has given you the answer.....
Anyhow, go buy a set and see how you get on
As for the other post.... VW MFSW MK7 Polo steering wheel in Mk5
Not even going there...sorry!
Err OK then. I thought the steering wheel was straight forward, there was a topic on this forum about fitting a mk7 GTI steering wheel into a mk5, and Eddie-NL put a post up seeming to suggest sourcing a Polo GTi one which is the same wheel as the mk7 GTi but with different buttons minus the cruise buttons on the wheel would work and illuminate, was just checking that was the case, dont see whats difficult about answering that question?
-
No the stalks will not fit.
If you want a mk7 style MFSW you'll need to search one down from the Scirocco. Then depending the year of your mk5 you'll need to change steering wheel electronic to module "CH".. cruise control stalk to "G", new wiper stalk without trip buttons and also possible a new tow ring for the steering wheel.
-
Seat Ibiza, VW Polo, Seat Toledo, Skoda Rapid ALL had mk5 stalks up till about 2014, and now have mk7 stalks, they surely havent completely redesigned everything on those cars to fit stalks that look slightly different, so must be the same fitting as the mk5 ones so must surely work? even if the mk7 ones are a different fitting, surely the mk7 style ones from these cars will fit and work?
I've got a 2009 Seat Ibiza (current shape, pre-facelift) as well as a 2008 MK5 Gti and the stalks are almost nothing alike apart from they perform the same functions. I know for a fact the polo ones are the same.