MK5 Golf GTI

All Things Mk5 => Mk5 General Area => Topic started by: imprezzaworks on January 04, 2020, 11:06:10 am

Title: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: imprezzaworks on January 04, 2020, 11:06:10 am
Looking at servicing the car in the next few weeks. Owned the car since November.


I 'may' look into getting the car mapped (r-tech) but it won't be anytime soon.

So stick to a standard filter or aftermarket, (non oiled?')
Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: pudding on January 04, 2020, 04:45:10 pm
I'd go with the Pipercross dry foam personally.   I haven't done dyno comparisons but the Pipercross definitely feels a little livlier than the paper filter.  It won't blow your skirt up but there's an improvement all the same.

Oiled filters have no place in a MAF metered engine.  No matter how closely you follow the oiling instructions, some of it always finds it's way onto the MAF element. 

VW didn't oil the paper element, and neither did Pipercross with their foam.  If you can't make a filter that doesn't need oil to grab hold of the dirt that gets past the filtration media, don't make it!  I've literally seen daylight peering through cotton gauze filters holding it up to the sky.  They are utter dog poop, don't use them.
Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: titchy on January 04, 2020, 07:16:51 pm
I have just fitted a Ramair let you know how it goes
Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: TheBALDpuma on January 09, 2020, 08:58:02 am
I'd go with the Pipercross dry foam personally.   I haven't done dyno comparisons but the Pipercross definitely feels a little livlier than the paper filter.  It won't blow your skirt up but there's an improvement all the same.

Oiled filters have no place in a MAF metered engine.  No matter how closely you follow the oiling instructions, some of it always finds it's way onto the MAF element. 

VW didn't oil the paper element, and neither did Pipercross with their foam.  If you can't make a filter that doesn't need oil to grab hold of the dirt that gets past the filtration media, don't make it!  I've literally seen daylight peering through cotton gauze filters holding it up to the sky.  They are utter dog poop, don't use them.

Does a filter like this give it a growlier induction noise?  That's all I want really  :grin:
Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: bobby_fodge on January 09, 2020, 10:03:59 am
I've got a aftermarket panel filter and I can't detect any more noise than the standard paper one.

Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: imprezzaworks on January 10, 2020, 04:23:27 pm
Cheers guys. Ended up with a standard item, all good.
Title: Re: Yay another panel filter question :)
Post by: pudding on January 10, 2020, 05:38:14 pm
I'd go with the Pipercross dry foam personally.   I haven't done dyno comparisons but the Pipercross definitely feels a little livlier than the paper filter.  It won't blow your skirt up but there's an improvement all the same.

Oiled filters have no place in a MAF metered engine.  No matter how closely you follow the oiling instructions, some of it always finds it's way onto the MAF element. 

VW didn't oil the paper element, and neither did Pipercross with their foam.  If you can't make a filter that doesn't need oil to grab hold of the dirt that gets past the filtration media, don't make it!  I've literally seen daylight peering through cotton gauze filters holding it up to the sky.  They are utter dog poop, don't use them.

Does a filter like this give it a growlier induction noise?  That's all I want really  :grin:

Nope! You need an induction kit for that!