MK5 Golf GTI
All Things Mk5 => Modifications & Technical Area => Performance Modifications => Topic started by: Carrera2RS on January 03, 2011, 12:37:53 pm
-
I am currently looking for an ED30, I may do a deal on Tuesday on a car at my local dealer.
I want to sort the suspension out and tighten things up. I have had M5's with PSS9, and roll bars plus more recently an E92M3 which I have H&R springs an was looking at a Ground Control kit.
Having read a lot of the threads seems that the KW V3 or PSS10/9 are the best built kits, I would like to sort out the suspension for fast road only, I dislike roll and understeer probably more than most.
I am thinking WALK, perhaps some front bushes, VWR or KW/Bilstein, Eibach or other roll bars (Not sure is VWR have a better front and rear balance than Eibach and stiffer ?)
I will probably leave the engine tweaking for now, I can worry about that once the Chassis is sorted
Anyone comment on the capabilities of and suitability for this job
AMD, VWR, VAGTech or others I am based in Hertfordshire so MK is close enough
I understand VWR have a good rep, but seems they may be pricey and perhaps more focussed on racing ?
I also want to make sure the car is looked after and supported by the same place for engine mods later and any other adjustments, plus be happy to sell the car on knowing it has been supported by one reputable company.
-
VWRs aftersales can be somewhat sketchy due to their racing commitments from what i gather, plus alot of their stuff seems to me to be rebadged with inflated prices. their racing suspension is KW with their own spring ratings. (Could well be the same though,just recoloured, who knows)
The KW V3s are very good indeed and ride very well. they are awkward to adjust once fitted though. the bilsteins can be adjusted much easier once fitted as the adjustment knobs are at the base. Also there are PSS10's out now.
Reference ARBs, the eibach even with the front on soft and rear on stiff gives a very neutral handling car. I was close to buying a new larger rear bar to make it more rear biased before is old up. if your coming from an M3 id say you want to go for a more rear biased ARB set up. Id be tempted with the whiteline front and rears myself. The WALK is a very good bit of kit, or maybe Whiteline adjustable front ARB, with the BSH rear 27mm adjustable ARB.
If your after a really good chassis, id say you also want to consider the TT lower control arms (some for sale for bargain price in the for sale section). this allows more adjustablity with you front camber as well as les unsprung weight.
You might want to look into a diff, coming from high end RWD super saloons you'll be used to great traction.
What is your budget for the chassis.
Also if your interested in what an Ed30 can manage with just an exhaust/intake, fuel pump and remap then have a watch of these. They really are quick cars, on the std turbo you'll hit between 330-360Hp for only around about £2500
GIAC Stage 3 (Revo Stage 2+ equivlent), so HPFP, TBE, Intake, FMIC and software... V's
Modded E39 M5 (440+bhp)
Modded 135i
E46 M3 (Missed gear, but still got it's ass on a platter anyway :grin: )..
Still can't help but be impressed with what a modded KO4 can compete against TBH :surprised: As you will notice, these aren't a short blast either and speeds get to around 150+ AND IT'S A HEAVY ASS 5 DOOR MANUAL!!! :laugh:
-
heres info on the TT lower arms
http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,13910.0.html (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,13910.0.html)
check the product review section. lots of info on mods. also ghave a look at engine mounts as the stock ones are quite sloppy
-
Thanks, guys I have continued to read.
My Budget is get the car to be as tight as possible and not skimp, but this is a car I want to use for every day for 12m and beyond, Im hoping to get a nice RWD (sorry) car for weekends in Autumn this year.
I was hoping to sort the handling out for £2k all in if possible, I hope the get a car for £15k, add £2k for suspension then perhaps stage 1 and exhaust for another £1k
If all in it is neat, sorted, looks more like it should (-20mm) is annoyingly capable at crushing miles and irritating more exotica in real world driving, perfect. : :wink:
I am actually quite excited about a GTi as my first real car was a Golf GTi 16v MkII, followed by a VR6, Corrado 16V and then on to other German cars....
I am thinking of a local dealer car and red, but really want an 08 20k miles, mint 3 door manual in black !
-
for 2 k i would be getting
WALK £140
whiteline ARBs front and rear £300
TT lower control arms £300-350
THS Engine mounts (full set) £245
Bilstein B12 springs/damper combo £600-£700 probably the best compromise between performance and comfort.
i found coilovers a little to harsh for UK roads. pot hole central where i live. coilovers are more for track IMO and you could probably add another £300+ easily.
that's about £1700. but it would make a really competent fast road car, you could maybe use the remaining cash for either fitting poly bushes every where else, or put it towards fitting
-
Tks,
I'll probably call AMD, VWR and VAGTech, and perhaps one other ?
All are a reasonable short drive away :wink:
-
AMD have quite an extortionate labour rate. £70/hour iirc where are you based
-
Howdy,
This sounds oddly familiar to me... in august I swapped from a 400 bhp 135i to a Porsche Booster S and an Edition 30 for the commute.
I've since modified the Ed30 to Stage 2+ (around 380 bhp) and I love it. If your anywhere in the north (Sheffield) I will HEARTILY recommend my tuner over any of the popular tuning 'brands' I see around here. I've never been so happy with the buying or aftersales service I received.
Anyway, they run two Edition 30's with hybrid turbos and about 430 bhp.... noting you're not after power, one of the guys also has the PSS10 kit while the other has just a set of lowering springs. Some good comparisons for you.
They also fitted a quaiffe LSD to my car for the previous owner.... I'd recommend that as a night/day level of mod. Just awesome.
Matt
-
We are in MK. Check out our website. www.backdraftmotorsport.com
Also work on Porsches and have a Boxster Spyder demo car with a few little mods :wink:
-
Thanks chaps.
My current thinking is
PSS10, nuespeed ARB's, WALK,
Then consider stage 1 chip and perhaps a miltek catback to add a little vocal accompaniment. I figure 300 ish running shell vmax and a sorted chassis will hopefully be adequate.
I'd like bigger brakes and an LSD, I will consider these after I see how acceptable the car is as a fast road everyday car before committing
I want to save for a gen II 997 GT3 and hope I can pick one up next winter as the attraction of a potential new model is on the grapevine and winter is looking long and horrible. Sub £80k for a low miler should be doable, they are nearer list and £90k today.
But I do want to get a hot hatch inwill love as most of my time will be spent in it !
-
Thanks chaps.
My current thinking is
PSS10, nuespeed ARB's, WALK,
I'd like bigger brakes and an LSD, I will consider these after I see how acceptable the car is as a fast road everyday car before committing
Then consider stage 1 chip and perhaps a miltek catback to add a little vocal accompaniment. I figure 300 ish running shell vmax and a sorted chassis will hopefully be adequate.
that will be very adequate. it might be worth considering a pad/fluid upgrade to improve the brakes grip. If you consider that the S3/R32/Cupra all have 345mm brakes as standard to cope with the extra power they have (all well below 300hp as well). that said the R32/S3 brake setup is only a cheap mod. there are always sets on here going for around £250.
-
Well I have found a 2007 black 3 door manual with 23k miles, from a dealer, I will pick up the weekend after next :happy2:
I am still unsure as to which way to go with mods. Deinites are a Miltek back box, probably non res ? Either KW/Billies or VWR coilovers, ARB's so long as they are adjustable all look fine so either Neus, eibach, HR VWR etc. Probably a walk, some say not necessary with stiffer coils ?
Then Short shift to finish off. I will then consider a stage 1
Any votes for VWR, VAGtech or AMD as they are close enough to me ?
By the way any further thoughts on resale. Do people think if it was modded by VWR or AMD it might have credibility. What about credibility of VWR products on resale ?
-
Well following a few more conversations I am going for .....
Bilstein PSS9 or 10
WALK
Neuspeed ARB's
Miltek Catback
I will pick my 23k mile, 1 owner black 3door next weekend :happy2: it will be stock for a week only :evilgrin:
-
Any votes for VWR, VAGtech or AMD as they are close enough to me ?
By the way any further thoughts on resale. Do people think if it was modded by VWR or AMD it might have credibility. What about credibility of VWR products on resale ?
....I vote for VWR without any hesitation. I'm fairly certain I was the first person from this forum to go there. MatED30 is a fanboy too. They even service my car - Had a oil service and DSG service yesterday and every 10k miles. I drive a 340 mile round trip to MK.
-
Well following a few more conversations I am going for .....
Bilstein PSS9 or 10
WALK
Neuspeed ARB's
Miltek Catback
I will pick my 23k mile, 1 owner black 3door next weekend :happy2: it will be stock for a week only :evilgrin:
Id add the lower engine mount tothat as well. only another £100'ish but it'll get rid of the slop in the engine/transmission
-
Any issues with NVH into the car ?
-
NVH??
-
NVH??
Noise, vibration and harshness. :smiley:
-
Any issues with NVH into the car ?
....It's not clear to me who you're asking, but plenty of NVH with aftermarket harder engine mounts and coilover suspension but I don't call it "NVH", I call it "Feedback" and I'd much rather have it that way. The noise is mostly exhaust music with some Grrrrr from the engine mounts and lower gear whine. The vibration is just a light buzz occasionally and the ride is hard but not harsh unless you're fool enough to drive too fast over large potholes. Plenty of squeaks from the cabin plastics. It might be a comfy 5-door car you can drive all day and never feel tired but mine isn't a marshmallow caccoon family saloon.
Carbonfibre bonnet with no soundproofing also helps. It all depends what you want from your car - Each To Their Own :happy2:
-
It is a balance....
A full rose jointed suspension can feel great on super smooth tracks n bloody awful on anything but :wink:
I personally want to avoid the 'crash, judder, shimmer' and have an engaging every day drive
-
the ARBs, WALK will not change any of the NVH. The coilovers will/wont dependant on the roads. The good thing about the bilsteins is you can have a road and a track set up, therefore the best of both worlds, especially as they are so easy to adjust.
-
the ARBs, WALK will not change any of the NVH. The coilovers will/wont dependant on the roads. The good thing about the bilsteins is you can have a road and a track set up, therefore the best of both worlds, especially as they are so easy to adjust.
....That's definitely one of the advantages of Bilstein over KW but I find the KW-V3's a perfect compromise for fast road and occasional trackday use and don't feel the need for further adjustment for each session.
As Carrera2RS says, it's definitely a balance. I would only add that what feels a comfortable ride for one person isn't for another.
-
I hope I can get the right balance with the Billies, as I understand the KW v3's and PSS9/10's are similar when set up correctly, or appropriately
I have also used Eibach coilovers, Koni struts and springs and a PSS9 kit on the same car (an E39 M5) and really liked the PSS9 as it was so adjustable, with some prior experience of setting up suspension (but not nearly enough !) It took some time to get a balance that I liked. My girlfriend did get a bit bored of lay-by's as they were usually an opportunity for me to get out, lean under the car and adjust.....
Having spoken to a few that do know what they are doing, I recognise the potential for me to get very lost with bump and rebound... 10 settings front and rear, easy adjustment with a kit I have used before persuaded me :smiley:
I am very happy with a well damped thud and slight skipping over undulating surfaces, much less happy with 'crashing' over bumps. My last car was superb in this respect, an E90 M3 with nothing more than H&R springs. I fitted them quite quickly after purchase and never wanted to change after. I just moved from middle to full stiff depending how much I was pushing the car. The 'hard' setting felt a little skittish unless you were really loading it up. The 'comfort' was juts too soft for me, I don't want to drive a limo even in traffic.
I hope I can get a compromise to suit :scared:
-
^^^^
Sounds as if you know exactly what you want to achieve. You'll get there even if after a few lay-by's - Remind the gf how patiently you wait outside while she does some shopping :evilgrin:
-
I'll keep you all posted. The car will be havingt he suspension fitted on the 8th/9th Feb :happy2:
-
with that in mind id probably purchase all the kit, then get VWR to fit it all for you. Probably better equipped with the knowledge to setting it up than any other independent VAG 'specialists' out there