MK5 Golf GTI

All Things Mk5 => Mk5 General Area => Topic started by: Rustybear on May 15, 2012, 09:27:22 pm

Title: Views
Post by: Rustybear on May 15, 2012, 09:27:22 pm

Now I know this is the wrong to ask!!! However, been offered a straight swap on my 2006 gti 96k fvwsh for a BMW 318ci msport 2003 with 70k. BMW lovely car but not sure about power etc. Golf is better car but my mileage is starting to only slightly worry me. Anyone with experience of swapping golf for 318ci msport, whT thy like etc. I am stronger feelings on gti as i love it but was wondering thoughts on mileage on it from experts as such.

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Mk5 GTian on May 15, 2012, 09:34:11 pm

It's a lovely shape the E46 coupe, but your car is worth around 6-6.5k, and a 318ci 2003 only about 4 4.5. Also the 318 is hopelessly underpowered, I've driven one.

If it was a 330ci M sport, I'd say go for it, or even a 325, but not the 318. I reckon you'd regret it big time.

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Greeners on May 15, 2012, 09:35:14 pm

You'd be mad to swap!!  :stupid:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Rustybear on May 15, 2012, 09:37:15 pm

So don't worry to much re mileage on the golf then?

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Greeners on May 15, 2012, 09:42:30 pm

Quote from: Rustybear on May 15, 2012, 09:37:15 pm

So don't worry to much re mileage on the golf then?

Well as many on here are well past 100k and still going strong I'd say no!  :happy2:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Mk5 GTian on May 15, 2012, 09:49:22 pm

Mine is a 2006 55 plate with 95K, and my garage said it is running superbly. I've had 3 Golfs with well over 100k on them:

1989 GTi 16V, sold with 213K
2001 V6 4Motion sold with 153K
1999 1.8T Gti sold with 116K

All were in excellent order. As long as they're maintained properly, there is nothing to fear on high mileage. 95K isn't even considered a high mileage for German cars nowadays anyhow. Don't worry Rusty, enjoy your car for many more miles  :happy2:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: jimmy-s3 on May 15, 2012, 10:08:20 pm

Dont do it..
I had a 2006 320i Msport touring and it was so underpowered

Title: Re: Views
Post by: PDT on May 15, 2012, 10:20:05 pm

Dont swap, theres tons of 318i msports out there for £3k, hard car to sell.

Believe it or not, cars dont suddenly destroy themselfes at 100k miles, its just a number.

Title: Re: Views
Post by: NiceRS on May 15, 2012, 10:26:04 pm

GTi all day :happy2: as said before nice looking car but wrong engine .

Title: Re: Views
Post by: greygti on May 15, 2012, 10:30:16 pm

Yea as GTian has said if it were a 325i or a 330i maybe a swap might be worth it , but what PDT has said also is bang on- just because your gti is heading for 100k does'nt mean its gonna go bang if it's been looked after, serviced regular and had a reasonable amount of mechanical sympathy it'll be just fine !

DONT SWAP FOR A 318I lol :smiley:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: MC71 on May 15, 2012, 11:07:34 pm

I would keep the GTI every day of the week over the 318i (330ci would be a different story though) AND as others have said your car is worth more. On a mk5 Golf forum we are probably biased but your car has a FSH with VW so is probably in good nick as well, keep it!!
 :happy2:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: da_ansa on May 16, 2012, 02:30:25 pm

ive owned the 328ci and my mate had the 318ci no way would i swap my golf not even for a 330ci

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Kregiel on May 16, 2012, 05:10:00 pm

I wouldn't go for it! mark 5 interior is much nicer than e46 regardless of the spec,

I considered E46 m3 some time back and one sat in it I thought I am in 1995 car serisouly, crappy plastics ect

Paul

Title: Re: Views
Post by: E30Dom on May 16, 2012, 05:15:53 pm

You even considered it enough to make a post about it  :signLOL:

 :stupid:

Title: Re: Views
Post by: Kregiel on May 16, 2012, 05:19:20 pm

Quote from: E30Dom on May 16, 2012, 05:15:53 pm

You even considered it enough to make a post about it  :signLOL:

 :stupid:

Come on Dom, this is your constructive comment??

 :pomppomp: