MK5 Golf GTI

General => Random Chat => Topic started by: Baz300 on November 17, 2012, 11:17:31 am

Title: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Baz300 on November 17, 2012, 11:17:31 am
I have been bidding on an item on eBay but every time I increase my bid the same 2 users place other bids within a few minutes of each other forcing the price up, as soon as they get above my max bid it seems to stop then when I increase my bid a few hours later the same 2 start again.  I tried bidding £10 more than what the item was at and I was the highest bidder again but outbid by one of them again

The seller also has a few other items up for sale and the same 2 bidders appear to be doing exactly the  same,

Should I report this to eBay ar just wait untill another one comes up for sale? As they have bidded past what the item is realistically worth
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: MC71 on November 17, 2012, 11:26:56 am
Report it ASAP, I always report it when I come across it, I annoys the s**t out of me. eBay take it pretty seriously and will suspend their accounts while they look into it. Oh and bid on another in the mean time.

 :happy2:

Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Eddie-NL on November 17, 2012, 03:54:43 pm
always bid at the last few seconds, before the item ends
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: gizmo68 on November 17, 2012, 04:15:37 pm
always bid at the last few seconds, before the item ends

+1 this is the only way IMO.

Bid what you are prepared to pay and not ‘just enough to win the auction’, if you win great, if not then it sold for more than you valued it anyway so no loss to you.
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Cupra R on November 17, 2012, 04:25:53 pm
always bid at the last few seconds, before the item ends

+1 this is the only way IMO.

Bid what you are prepared to pay and not ‘just enough to win the auction’, if you win great, if not then it sold for more than you valued it anyway so no loss to you.

Agreed. I think this is the best way too.
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Squeeguk on November 17, 2012, 05:02:02 pm
Yeah and then you get those that place shill bids and then come back after the auction has ended and say the other person decided they didn't want it any more. The same 'person' who has bumped up the price of the item substantially. I been done like that a few times. It's really annoying.
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Baz300 on November 17, 2012, 05:07:47 pm
I did report them but eBay does Not think it is unusual activity.as they do not live in the same house?
Both items are almost at there brand new cost even though they are used

I always just bid what i am willing to pay and leave it,
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: MC71 on November 17, 2012, 05:23:44 pm
I did report them but eBay does Not think it is unusual activity.as they do not live in the same house?
Both items are almost at there brand new cost even though they are used

I always just bid what i am willing to pay and leave it,

I actually laughed out loud when I read that, what a ridiculous statement for them to come up with! One would assume, obviously incorrectly, that they would have a team of people to deal with this sort of thing but as this does not affect their bottom line I don't suppose they're to bothered.  :stupid:

You know this practice happens on something your bidding on (which you subsequently lose) when you receive a "second chance offer" after the auctions ended.

As you say, it's no biggy to you as you only bid what you consider to be the worth of that item to you.   :happy2:
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Baz300 on November 17, 2012, 05:27:06 pm
I won't be accepting the second chance offer if I do get one

But the price that it has been pushed up to I would rather just buy the item brand new
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: gobbleplease on November 17, 2012, 08:06:53 pm
Tbh I've sold a lot of things where the highest bidder has spent way too much on an item and decides not to pay then you offer it down and know one pays you just need to re advertise It !
Fookin hate ebay you can't even give these dicks a bad review any more !!!

You can tell those bidders a mile off ! At the end of the day bid what you want to pay and don't go any further and defintootly report them !
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: SteveyD on November 19, 2012, 10:28:45 pm
Shill bidding f*****g winds me the f**k up really gets on my t**s how people doing it think we are all so naive to not cotton on.  Iv lost count on how many times I have reported this to eBay including cases recently where cars pop up on 7 day auctions yet within mins they are bid up to thousands, well above book and of course re-listed the day after the auction ends.  One guy I noticed had THREE accounts! simple fact eBay do not give a damn about this practice, they get paid regardless in one way or another and only seem to act when they have absolutely no excuse not too.

These days it's very rare ill get involved in an auction, I prefer to use but it now or best offer.  I'd usually say it's the minority who spoil it for the majority but with shill bidding ill stick my neck on the line and suggest 80% of auctions are bumped up this way.
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Emilwy on November 20, 2012, 02:15:02 am
I'm looking to buy a MK5 golf LEATHER ARMREST on ebay and it as 1 bid at £150. It's just an armrest. Do I just keep my cloth one ??
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Deako on November 20, 2012, 08:11:23 am
I was 2nd highest bidder on an Ibiza Cupra Sport. Low and behold, day after the "winning bidder had pulled out". Now, it could have been a genuine bidder, as the car was a complete shed. It could have been a shill bidder. Who knows. Needless to say, i wasted a 180 mile round trip last night.
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Tamiyoman on November 20, 2012, 10:40:48 am
www.bidnapper.com is the answer your issues (I have been using them for 3-4 years), just put in your maximum bid at any time before auction end (2-3 days before end is normal for me) and it will bid for you with 2-5 seconds left, Thus not giving the shillers a chance to push it up, it's the only way i buy on auctions as shill bidding is very common these days.

Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: sub39h on November 20, 2012, 07:51:54 pm
always bid at the last few seconds, before the item ends

all about sniping. managed to snag a couple of items for a couple of quid more than the maximum and avoided getting into a bidding war in the process  :happy2:
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Tamiyoman on December 18, 2012, 11:58:24 pm
Angry emails from a seller after I used Bidnapper on his auction item............

I was watching the item for 6 days and no bidders (1 day left), item start price £49.99, put a bid on of £50.77, within 30 minutes its bid to £51 by a buyer with 7 feedback, I raise my bid to £55, 20 mins later the same bidder bids 5 more times in £1 increments to £56 so i figured balls to it, will leave it (Item is new and retails at £145 but box is damaged, contents are fine and i throw boxes away so im not fussed about that, so figure will leave it at that), had a look at sellers feedback and the bidder has won one of his previous items (whats the chances of that with 7 feedback  :grin:), so I retract my bids and it goes back to £49.99 with him winning.

I Contacted Ebay who "could not confirm what action would be taken, but there would be action taken against the seller  :confused: (I guess he was shilling but they cannot confirm it to me), anyhoo fast forward 22hrs and I used the sniper and got it for £50  :signLOL: :signLOL:

I have received emails from a pretty stupid seller it seems................ emails go something like this..

Seller:- Oi whats goin on?, the other bidder emailed me saying he could not bid on my item!!!!, I am cancelling the sale, Thanks.

Me:- What is going on is that Ebay suspected you were bidding on your own items using another account, feel free to contact them about it!!, I have paid in full for the item and under Ebay policy we have entered into a contract (You as seller and me as buyer), failure to send me the item will result in you being reported to Ebay for breach of Ebay policy, likely being banned for shill bidding (feel free to look it up altho I suspect you know what it is) Breaking a contract (For which I am entitled to an equal replacement item at your cost) and of course the appropriate feedback will be placed.
Please ensure item is packed securely and despatched as per your listing (tomorrow) for delivery on thursday (Special delivery as per the service I paid for).

Seller:- I ave no idea what shill bidding is and ave not dun it, I am going to speak to ebay about this, your not getting the item at that price!!.

Me:- No worries, will speak to Ebay myself tomorrow about your conduct (I did indeed speak to Ebay about this).

45 minutes after my call to Ebay:-

Seller:- I am sending the item but am not happy, I feel you stole my item u shud be ashamed, it's christmas!!

Me:- I look forward to receiving my item.........................................Merry Christmas!  :grin: :grin:

Item arrived today absolutely spot on and a bargain!!!! (It is not a christmas present, well it is for me I suppose, pressie to myself), have not left feedback yet as am going to speak to Ebay again before I leave accurate feedback.

It looks like if Ebay do catch a shill bidder they remove their bids and block them from bidding (Altho both accounts still active), worked for me anyway. Normally I would only ever use a sniper but I ALWAYS put in a low bid to make sure it allows my bid as some sellers have some serious restrictions and lost a great item few years ago from that so always do it this way now.



 
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Kemnaychris on December 19, 2012, 07:48:17 am
Haha winner takes all ;)

Christmas or not donr sell things with no reserve if u can't handle taking a huge loss lol nice one dude happy days :-)
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: JoeDarKa on December 19, 2012, 08:39:01 am
I never bid on anything before the last 15secs anyway. If you bid early it gives other people time to think that they will bid higher!
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: JackG on December 19, 2012, 08:47:09 am
I've placed an initial bid on something that's linked from the forum, within the time I placed my bid to the time it would have taken to make a phone call (seller that is) I was outbid straight away,  same person with same feedback too, I haven't reported it yet but will keep an eye out and then I will, ebay just seems to have had its day now and is just full of people conning all the time :fighting:
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Tamiyoman on December 19, 2012, 10:37:49 am
I've placed an initial bid on something that's linked from the forum, within the time I placed my bid to the time it would have taken to make a phone call (seller that is) I was outbid straight away,  same person with same feedback too, I haven't reported it yet but will keep an eye out and then I will, ebay just seems to have had its day now and is just full of people conning all the time :fighting:

Agreed there are so many scammers on Ebay, I ship most items tracked mail now (at buyers cost) because of this, 3-4 years ago we used to ship std mail which saved buyers money but now it's not worth the risk, paypal fraud, shill bidding, credit card fraud, idiots leaving negative feedback because they bought the wrong item, the list goes on............................
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: JackG on December 19, 2012, 01:38:21 pm
I've placed an initial bid on something that's linked from the forum, within the time I placed my bid to the time it would have taken to make a phone call (seller that is) I was outbid straight away,  same person with same feedback too, I haven't reported it yet but will keep an eye out and then I will, ebay just seems to have had its day now and is just full of people conning all the time :fighting:

Agreed there are so many scammers on Ebay, I ship most items tracked mail now (at buyers cost) because of this, 3-4 years ago we used to ship std mail which saved buyers money but now it's not worth the risk, paypal fraud, shill bidding, credit card fraud, idiots leaving negative feedback because they bought the wrong item, the list goes on............................

Good point, there is very few genuine sales on eBay, I've heard stories of people buying cars on there with bidding to go and collect the car and reduce there bid price once it's been sold, I'm really paranoid on there now, I'll only buy phone cases and little things,  I'll pay more for piece of mind, its certainly not cheaper too....I was looking for some genuine screen wash the other day, saw a place selling some for 5.99+1.99 p&p ... it's about 2.50+vat from the dealers :stupid:
I certainly think they need to change the rule book, I even see people selling "Xbox 360 elite 250gb box" fait enough the people should read it properly but it's somone trying to catch somone out and there is nothing eBay can do about it,  it gives the company a bad name...I've even found badoo prostitue on there  :signLOL:
http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=160941437956
Title: Re: eBay shill bidding
Post by: Tamiyoman on December 19, 2012, 02:02:59 pm
I've placed an initial bid on something that's linked from the forum, within the time I placed my bid to the time it would have taken to make a phone call (seller that is) I was outbid straight away,  same person with same feedback too, I haven't reported it yet but will keep an eye out and then I will, ebay just seems to have had its day now and is just full of people conning all the time :fighting:

Agreed there are so many scammers on Ebay, I ship most items tracked mail now (at buyers cost) because of this, 3-4 years ago we used to ship std mail which saved buyers money but now it's not worth the risk, paypal fraud, shill bidding, credit card fraud, idiots leaving negative feedback because they bought the wrong item, the list goes on............................

Good point, there is very few genuine sales on eBay, I've heard stories of people buying cars on there with bidding to go and collect the car and reduce there bid price once it's been sold, I'm really paranoid on there now, I'll only buy phone cases and little things,  I'll pay more for piece of mind, its certainly not cheaper too....I was looking for some genuine screen wash the other day, saw a place selling some for 5.99+1.99 p&p ... it's about 2.50+vat from the dealers :stupid:
I certainly think they need to change the rule book, I even see people selling "Xbox 360 elite 250gb box" fait enough the people should read it properly but it's somone trying to catch somone out and there is nothing eBay can do about it,  it gives the company a bad name...I've even found badoo prostitue on there  :signLOL:
http://pages.ebay.com/link/?nav=item.view&id=160941437956

I have been on Ebay since 2002 (joined up to sell my world cup tickets for Englands group games as my best mate broke his leg and could not travel, we tripled our money on the tickets tho  :happy2:), and back then Ebay was great, it was genuine people selling stuff, around 2006/7 it started going downhill fast!.
I sell on there regularly but buyers pay for tracked mail (with confirmed paypal accounts) so I dont lose the money and the item.

Been ripped off twice on Ebay in 10 years, one by a yank selling a toy (Got my money back tho  :happy2:) and another time by some scrote in London who said he never received it then had the balls to put pictures of the item up on a collectors forum ( :fighting:), I worked in London regularly so went round with a mate holding a "clipboard" and told him we we here to collect.....................little sh%t handed it over very quickly and off we went, never to be heard from again  :signLOL: