MK5 Golf GTI

All Things Mk5 => Mk5 General Area => Topic started by: Craigh1983 on April 24, 2013, 07:53:52 am

Title: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Craigh1983 on April 24, 2013, 07:53:52 am
Hey guys,

Just had my Golf GTI mk5 remapped by R-tech to stage-1. I have to say the results were absolutely fantastic and the guys there are such a good bunch!

So when Nick was doing the health check on my car he noticed that when I had the middle and back box of my exhaust changed, the company had used a smaller pipe than the original, which is restricting the car slightly.

He mentioned getting a Milltek system. However after looking at the price of these I don't think I could afford one of them soon.
I could however get a second hand standard GTI exhaust. Would there be a massive difference in the car if I held off for a while and got the Milltek or at stage 1 would a standard exhaust do just the same job?

Cheers

Craigh
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Tortaruga on April 24, 2013, 08:52:18 am
Standard exhaust is plenty good enough for stage 1. Afaik you can even go stage 2 with it, although a Milltek would free up the power better.

You could knock out the precat in the gti exhaust - might help a bit, although some people complain about extra noise-do a search for 'precat delete'.
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: bushypad on April 24, 2013, 09:12:50 am
I recently went from standard to a full milltek turboback non res with decat and the difference is immediate.. Its much more raspy and as you rev higher has a lovely deep tone to it and it sounds better the more miles you put on it.. Im on a stage one but the car feels quicker since adding the exhaust too
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: nutey on April 24, 2013, 09:21:41 am
I recently went from standard to a full milltek turboback non res with decat and the difference is immediate.. Its much more raspy and as you rev higher has a lovely deep tone to it and it sounds better the more miles you put on it.. Im on a stage one but the car feels quicker since adding the exhaust too

Do you find the exhaust drony (is that a word?) when cruising? It's one of the mods I'd like to do when I find the right car...
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: john87 on April 24, 2013, 09:49:38 am
I also have a turbo-back system (Custom front half inc. 200 cell cat, Milltek from cat-back) and don't find it drony when cruising below 90mph 70mph  :laugh:

Almost as quiet as the OEM system when maintaining a steady speed but a nice warm burble when booting it!
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: bushypad on April 24, 2013, 10:39:02 am
When you get above 85-90 yes it does drone a bit but doesn't bother me! At cruising speeds its just like standard but when you go above 5k rpm its a diff animal altogether.. And the twin tail pipes just look better fit nicely into the gap more snug!
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: nutey on April 24, 2013, 10:43:58 am
I also have a turbo-back system (Custom front half inc. 200 cell cat, Milltek from cat-back) and don't find it drony when cruising below 90mph 70mph  :laugh:

Almost as quiet as the OEM system when maintaining a steady speed but a nice warm burble when booting it!


What's the fitting like for a Turbo Back system? I looked into one for my S4 and it involved dropping the subframe and would end up almost as expensive in Labour as the exhaust itself :scared: I guess Cat Back is pretty straight forward
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: nutey on April 24, 2013, 10:48:19 am
PS Sorry for the thread hijack!! Hopefully the answers are useful for the OP :happy2:
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Craigh1983 on April 24, 2013, 11:22:31 am
[quote author=Tortaruga link=topic=65722.msg724026#msg724026 date

You could knock out the precat in the gti exhaust - might help a bit, although some people complain about extra noise-do a search for 'precat delete'.
[/quote]

I am definately thinking of knocking out the pre cat.

When I'm looking at these exhausts it is mentioning cat back. What is this? This all sounds quite complicated lol
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: GrayMK5GTI on April 24, 2013, 11:48:51 am
May be worth buying a used OEM exhaust off the forum / ebay to remove the restriction.

I'd advise using the Search function when choosing aftermarket. I went to the ring in a Non-Res Milltek R32 and it droned so much i was nearly deaf by the time I got there  :sick:

Put me off wanting a milltek, i would have been more inclined to go for BCS as its cheaper and customer service seems very good - i'm very much in support of "the little guys" on here  :happy2:
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: gigolo456 on April 24, 2013, 12:01:12 pm
X2 for the BCS...

Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: john87 on April 24, 2013, 12:01:53 pm
I also have a turbo-back system (Custom front half inc. 200 cell cat, Milltek from cat-back) and don't find it drony when cruising below 90mph 70mph  :laugh:

Almost as quiet as the OEM system when maintaining a steady speed but a nice warm burble when booting it!


What's the fitting like for a Turbo Back system? I looked into one for my S4 and it involved dropping the subframe and would end up almost as expensive in Labour as the exhaust itself :scared: I guess Cat Back is pretty straight forward

You can remove the turbo-back no problem, I even took my standard one off using axle stands!

The custom kit was later fitted on ramps
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: rob-gti on April 24, 2013, 05:04:50 pm
If your running a turbo back milltek system is it not a pain in the ass to revert back to the standard system for MOT?
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Kalpsn2000 on April 24, 2013, 05:12:58 pm
If your running a turbo back milltek system is it not a pain in the ass to revert back to the standard system for MOT?

Why would you need to?
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Jamie3184 on April 24, 2013, 05:14:06 pm
I was under the impression that the cat back part did next to nothing and it was mainly the downpipe that needed to be changed for stage 2. Surely the OP could get standard cat back but change the downpipe and cat for a 200 cell version?
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: alfboden on April 24, 2013, 05:15:28 pm
If your running a turbo back milltek system is it not a pain in the ass to revert back to the standard system for MOT?
If it has a sports cat you'll have no mot issues.
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: rob-gti on April 24, 2013, 05:28:30 pm
If your running a turbo back milltek system is it not a pain in the ass to revert back to the standard system for MOT?

Why would you need to?

For the emissions test!

If it has a sports cat you'll have no mot issues.

Good to know!  :happy2:
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: gigolo456 on April 24, 2013, 09:11:41 pm
My BCS has a sports cat, passed its MOT 2 wks ago, well emissions anyway!
Nick at R Tech last friday said last friday that he knows a lot of Milltek lads with sports cat who failed on emissions, that really surprised me! Is this really the case!? :-o
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Kalpsn2000 on April 24, 2013, 10:55:52 pm
If your running a turbo back milltek system is it not a pain in the ass to revert back to the standard system for MOT?

Why would you need to?

For the emissions test!

If it has a sports cat you'll have no mot issues.

Good to know!  :happy2:

As long it has a cat it should be fine. My BCS with sports cat passed fine last month :happy2:
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Kalpsn2000 on April 24, 2013, 10:58:02 pm
My BCS has a sports cat, passed its MOT 2 wks ago, well emissions anyway!
Nick at R Tech last friday said last friday that he knows a lot of Milltek lads with sports cat who failed on emissions, that really surprised me! Is this really the case!? :-o

Really! Would be massive hassle changing over (and back again) every year!
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Andy on April 24, 2013, 11:03:05 pm
aif the cat is a 200 cell it should pass fine-its the 100 cell cats that were touch and go whether it would pass the emissions
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: gigolo456 on April 24, 2013, 11:05:05 pm
Yeap, Nick's statement threw me completely!! If i'd thought there was any way that my shiny new sports cat exhaust would fail on emissions, i'd have given it a miss and chosen an alternative!!
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: gigolo456 on April 24, 2013, 11:07:03 pm
I take it then that my BCS Powervalve with sportscat is 200 cel??  :confused:
Title: Re: Milltek exhaust vs standard exhaust. Is there a big difference??
Post by: Jamie3184 on April 24, 2013, 11:40:16 pm
I take it then that my BCS Powervalve with sportscat is 200 cel??  :confused:

If it is a sports cat from BCS then i would assume its 200 cell, i've always known a sports cat to be 200 cell and a race cat to be 100 cell. BCS do offer both though in there systems.