MK5 Golf GTI

General => Random Chat => Topic started by: Black9 on September 08, 2013, 12:05:00 am

Title: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Black9 on September 08, 2013, 12:05:00 am
What's people's opinions?

I had my Le Mans Blue E39 M5 repainted in steel metallic grey. Job is extremely good and includes all door and boot shuts. Only part of car that's left blue is the engine bay.

Reason I ask is, I'm thinking of selling as I want back in another KO4 Golf :driver:
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: garrardrj on September 08, 2013, 02:01:03 pm
As you ask for opinions ....

Mine is that if a car that has been repainted from its original colour devalues it , especially if there are parts of it still visible of the original colour . I would never buy a car that was relatively new that had been . Classic and older cars are quite different as they quite often are resprayed due to the poor quality of the paint when they were built and also the deterioration that occurs over time . For a Car built 1990 onwards i would say most people would have my opinion  :innocent:
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: cuprajake on September 08, 2013, 03:55:59 pm
I change the colour on most of my cars and so far have always sold them for more than I paid.

If it's done right then there's no issue.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Black9 on September 08, 2013, 05:01:04 pm
As I say the only parts on the car that are the "old" colour is the engine bay. The rest is the new steel grey.

It's a 2000 M5 so hardly a new car.

All going well should sell for a good price
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: phil1975 on September 08, 2013, 05:42:00 pm
Most cars of a certain age require some paint so providing its been done well and the colour suits the car (sometimes a modern shade doesn't suit a period car) I don't see why not.

I agree that on a more modern car it might put me off, but as you say on 2000 plate I don't see a problem.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Deako on September 08, 2013, 08:52:57 pm
I'd personally feel more comfortable buying a car with certain prestige, like an M5, if it was in its factory colour.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Bow on September 08, 2013, 09:40:56 pm
I don't see why it should long as its done extremely good. Ie no orange peel, marks, old paint etc. also if nice colour surely more appealing. Could you post up a pic to show us please might answer your question more. I have been toying with the idea for my eddy as I'm a sucker for jazz blue :-)
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Black9 on September 08, 2013, 09:55:17 pm
It's steel metallic grey which is also used on the M3 CSL

I have no idea how to post pics but if someone pm's me Their email address I can send it to them and they can upload it if they don't mind....
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: doylebros on September 08, 2013, 10:03:09 pm
Like with all buyers:-

One man‟s meat is another man‟s poison.

So you never know but price seems to be the key (unless the colour is wicked).
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: tony_danza on September 10, 2013, 09:43:59 am
I don't think it'll de-value it as such, but it will limit your market.

An M5 of this vintage is going to be bought by an enthusiast, and one that's had paint for whatever reason will arouse suspicion as to why?? So long as you can demonstrate it wasn't accident damaged, and it's been done to a high standard, you'll be ok.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: MichaelR on September 11, 2013, 04:02:13 pm
I wouldn't buy a car that had been resprayed purely because of the thought of what damaged panels they could potentially be hiding.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Mk5 GTian on September 13, 2013, 06:41:52 pm

When I get my Ed30 I shall be looking into the possibility of repainting it in laser Blue. I reckon it would re-sell ok, as it's such a popular colour on the mk5 scene. In fact, if done properly, It might even add a premium. However, my number one priority is getting the car I want, as I fully intend keeping this one long-term, so the 'resellability' is secondary.

Your thread has, however highlighted the importance of having the engine removed. I'd be put off buying a car with a different colour in the engine bay. 
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: GrayMK5GTI on September 13, 2013, 09:18:58 pm
^^Ian you could always wrap it?

It protects the paintwork underneath and completely removable for when you come sell up. It's also cheaper than a respray and looks just as good  :happy2:

Getting more & more popular these days. BMW & Ford have both done it with their models.

For ideas: http://www.itsawrapuk.com/
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Mk5 GTian on September 13, 2013, 09:42:43 pm
^^Ian you could always wrap it?

It protects the paintwork underneath and completely removable for when you come sell up. It's also cheaper than a respray and looks just as good  :happy2:

Getting more & more popular these days. BMW & Ford have both done it with their models.

For ideas: http://www.itsawrapuk.com/

That's a good shout Graeme. Do you know if you can get wraps in OEM colours?
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: GrayMK5GTI on September 13, 2013, 10:49:28 pm
Says on the site they do 1000+ different colours, so there's a good chance  :happy2:

Loads of car "wrappers" out there, I'm sure someone could get Shadow Blue for you Ian  :innocent:
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Deako on September 14, 2013, 04:14:17 pm

When I get my Ed30 I shall be looking into the possibility of repainting it in laser Blue. I reckon it would re-sell ok, as it's such a popular colour on the mk5 scene. In fact, if done properly, It might even add a premium. However, my number one priority is getting the car I want, as I fully intend keeping this one long-term, so the 'resellability' is secondary.

Your thread has, however highlighted the importance of having the engine removed. I'd be put off buying a car with a different colour in the engine bay. 

I don't think anyone would buy an Edition 30 in a non factory colour.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: gobbleplease on September 14, 2013, 07:34:53 pm
Personally I wouldn't buy a resprayed car unless if was going very cheap !
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Callmedude on September 14, 2013, 07:43:12 pm
I personally think yes.

I wouldn't buy a car that has been resprayed and the engine bay left.

If I bought one respray the bay needs to be sprayed but I would want it cheaper than market value
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: MAT ED30 on September 14, 2013, 08:13:33 pm
just wrap it then its easy to remove after your done
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: dmac1969 on September 14, 2013, 09:24:52 pm

When I get my Ed30 I shall be looking into the possibility of repainting it in laser Blue. I reckon it would re-sell ok, as it's such a popular colour on the mk5 scene. In fact, if done properly, It might even add a premium. However, my number one priority is getting the car I want, as I fully intend keeping this one long-term, so the 'resellability' is secondary.

Your thread has, however highlighted the importance of having the engine removed. I'd be put off buying a car with a different colour in the engine bay.  

I don't think anyone would buy an Edition 30 in a non factory colour.

I would , if it was a colour I liked and the job had been done properly (engine out , windows out etc). I dont care about resale value , I care about enjoying what I have at the time , and if I liked the colour I would have it. For instance , i wouldnt mind an Orange one , or Bright Yellow , I like bright colours!
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: Black9 on September 14, 2013, 09:38:39 pm
I personally wouldn't buy a resprayed MK5 Golf due to it being a relatively newer car and the wide variation of desirable colours available for it.

As for an old car like a E39 M5. Most sub 10K cars need bodywork (if not already done) Most will need a Full respray.

IMO a car resprayed in a desirable colour which Wasnt available from factory will lower resale to some ppl and add to others.

Engine out respray is a monumental job. IMO not worth it on an old car
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: dmac1969 on September 14, 2013, 09:57:24 pm
I personally wouldn't buy a resprayed MK5 Golf due to it being a relatively newer car and the wide variation of desirable colours available for it.

As for an old car like a E39 M5. Most sub 10K cars need bodywork (if not already done) Most will need a Full respray.

IMO a car resprayed in a desirable colour which Wasnt available from factory will lower resale to some ppl and add to others.

Engine out respray is a monumental job. IMO not worth it on an old car

Early Mk5 Golfs are 10 years old! Early high milage GTIs go for about 4K now , a respray wont dent the price of a tatty car , in fact it would probably increase the value , as long as you find the right buyer!
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: tony_danza on September 15, 2013, 09:28:02 am
I know of a Scirocco that was stripped to a bare shell and painted S3 orange by an Audi dealer. I doubt that's been de-valued.

It's all about who did it and to what standard - You're never going to see a return on the money though, at best it'll fetch the same money as stock.
Title: Re: Does repainting a car, non factory devalue it
Post by: MAT ED30 on September 15, 2013, 11:27:38 am
I have a rocco local that's fully orange seen it loads I thought it was a wrap on this one but not looked close enough